How the home kits work
In part one, we saw that around 1 person in 6 believes they’ve had a food allergy, while only about 1 in 100reacts when properly tested. That gap is where home test kits thrive.
The process is simple. You prick your finger, fill a card with a few drops of blood and post it to a lab. The report that comes back sorts foods into low, medium and high, and usually recommends cutting the “high” ones, often followed by a retest a few weeks later.
The promises are big: identify allergies, intolerances or “sensitivities”, explain bloating and fatigue, and improve recovery and performance. To see whether the science backs that up, we need to look at what’s in the vial.
Two antibodies, two very different jobs
Almost all of these tests measure an antibody called immunoglobulin G (IgG), sometimes the subclass IgG4, against a panel of foods. Antibodies are proteins your immune system makes to tag foreign material. Two types matter here.
IgG: the most common antibody in your blood. After every meal, tiny amounts of food protein slip from your gut into your bloodstream. IgG helps clear them away quietly.
IgE: the antibody behind real food allergy. It sits on immune cells, and when it meets the food protein, those cells release histamine within minutes. That’s what causes hives, swollen lips, breathing problems and, in the worst case, anaphylaxis.
IgG doesn’t take part in that allergic chain reaction. A task force of the European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (EAACI) concluded that food-specific IgG4 reflects repeated exposure to a food and immune tolerance of it, not a cause of symptoms. In other words, a raised IgG is a normal response, not a red flag.
Why your report lists your favourite foods
If IgG shows up for foods you eat often, the results become very predictable. The “high” column is almost always filled with staples: milk, eggs, wheat. For a cyclist, that can mean bread, pasta, porridge and the energy bars in your jersey pocket. The test hasn’t found your problem foods. It has found your breakfast.

The opposite mistake is more worrying. Someone with a genuine IgE allergy may have low IgG to that food. A “low” result could then be read as permission to eat something that triggers a serious reaction, a risk the Canadian Society of Allergy and Clinical Immunology flagged explicitly.
And then there’s that word “sensitivity”. As we saw in part one, it has no agreed medical definition, so it can never be ruled out. If you cut foods and feel better, it’s tempting to credit the test, but symptoms often improve after any change in diet.
Other tests with the same problem
IgG panels aren’t the only option on the market. A review of unproven tests for food reactions looked at several others, including:
- Hair analysis.
- Electrodermal testing, which measures skin resistance to electrical current.
- Applied kinesiology, where your muscle strength is tested while you hold a food.
- Cytotoxic tests, which look at changes in white blood cells mixed with food extracts.
The verdict was blunt. Where they’ve been tested properly, these methods aren’t reproducible and don’t match real disease, and most lack any plausible biological basis.
Real allergy testing is targeted: it checks a specific suspicion that comes from your symptoms. A test that hands back a long list of foods to avoid, without asking about your history and without a food challenge, isn’t diagnosing anything.
What allergy experts say
On this question, the experts don’t disagree. The European Academy’s task force advised in 2008 that IgG4 testing for foods is irrelevant for diagnosing food allergy or intolerance and shouldn’t be done. American and Canadian allergy organisations took the same line. In the UK, NICE guidance on food allergy advises against IgG testing too, along with hair analysis and applied kinesiology.
The Canadians also spelt out the harms: unnecessary dietary restrictions and the risk of reintroducing a food a person is genuinely allergic to.
So, what does work? Proper diagnosis starts with a detailed history of your symptoms. Skin prick tests or specific IgE blood tests are then used to check a particular suspicion, and a supervised food challenge settles it. And as we saw in part one, being sensitised isn’t the same as being allergic.
A food sensitivity test reads your shopping list, not your gut. But if the test isn’t the answer, your symptoms still need an explanation. In the next part, we’ll look at the most common reasons cyclists’ stomachs rebel on the bike, and whether cutting gluten or FODMAPs actually helps.
